# Corporate Governance for UPSC GS4: Shareholders vs Stakeholders, Integrity and Efficiency, Private-Sector Corruption, PSU Boards and CSR

Source: https://tracknation.in/story/corporate-governance-for-upsc-gs4-shareholders-vs-stakeholders-integrity-and-efficiency-private-sector-corruption-psu-boards-and-csr (TrackNation — free UPSC notes with PYQs)

> Corporate governance and business ethics for UPSC GS4: principles of governance, Friedman vs stakeholder theory, moral integrity and professional efficiency, private-sector bribery and the 2018 PC Act amendment, UNCAC, PSU boards, mandatory CSR under Section 135 with FY 2024-25 spending, and business-ethics case studies.

## Corporate Governance, Shareholders and Stakeholders

🎯 **Exam priority: Important (Mains GS4).** *Asked directly in 2022 (is CSR efficient and sufficient, given the corporate sector's onslaught on the climate?) and 2023 (moral integrity and professional efficiency in corporate governance), and present in many Section B cases set inside companies, hospitals, tech firms and PSUs.*

## What corporate governance is

Corporate governance is the system by which companies are directed and controlled: how boards, managers, shareholders and other stakeholders share power and responsibility. Its core principles: **accountability** of management to the board and of the board to owners; **transparency** and honest disclosure; **fairness** to all shareholders, including minorities; **independence** of directors and auditors; and **responsibility** to stakeholders and society.

## For whom is a company run?

| ****

 | **Shareholder primacy**

 | **Stakeholder theory**

 |
| Claim

 | Managers' duty is to maximise profit for the owners

 | Managers should balance the interests of all who have a stake in the firm

 |
| Key thinker

 | Milton Friedman (1970 essay: business has a moral responsibility to increase profits)

 | Stakeholder theorists; stakeholders include employees, customers, shareholders and communities

 |
| Ethical basis

 | Duty to those who invested capital

 | Fairness to all affected parties

 |
| Risk

 | Cutting corners on safety, environment and labour

 | Vague accountability: managers answer to everyone and no one

 |

*Shareholder primacy against stakeholder theory, and the core principles of corporate governance.*

The **Firestone/Ford tyre crisis** (around 2000) shows why the debate matters: tyre failures caused thousands of accidents and 271 deaths worldwide, millions of tyres were recalled at a cost of billions, and executives lost their jobs. Cutting costs on safety may lift short-term profit but harms the public and, in the end, the firm itself.

## Moral integrity and professional efficiency (2023)

- **Moral integrity** in a company: honest accounts and disclosures, no bribery, fair dealing with workers, suppliers and minority shareholders, and refusal to profit from harm (unsafe products, pollution).

- **Professional efficiency:** competent management, sound risk control, timely decisions and effective use of capital.

- **Why both:** efficiency without integrity produces fraud that destroys value and trust; integrity without efficiency produces honest failure. Good governance needs independent boards, strong audit committees, whistleblower channels and a code of ethics covering bribery, discrimination and whistleblowing.

## Corruption, Compliance and PSUs

## Corruption and the private sector

- The 2nd ARC cites Transparency International's **Bribe Payers Index 2006**, where businesses from India, China and Russia, at the bottom of the index, showed the greatest propensity to pay bribes.

- It notes that private-sector corruption was then outside the Prevention of Corruption Act, and recommended bringing private agencies delivering public services, and NGOs spending substantial public money, within it.

- The **UN Convention against Corruption (Article 12)** asks states to prevent private-sector corruption through accounting and audit standards, prohibiting practices such as **off-the-books accounts**.

- **The 2018 amendment to the Prevention of Corruption Act** made giving or promising an undue advantage to induce improper performance of public duty an offence (up to seven years) and made a **commercial organisation** liable to a fine when anyone associated with it bribes a public servant to obtain or retain business; its defence is to prove it had **adequate procedures** in place to prevent such conduct. This pushes companies to build compliance systems.

## Government as owner: PSUs

For public sector undertakings, the state is both owner and regulator. The 2nd ARC saw a **conflict of interest** in nominating serving officials to PSU boards, since an official may later sit in judgment over decisions he took as a board member, and suggested not nominating them.

## CSR and Business Ethics in Case Studies

## Corporate social responsibility (2022)

India made CSR a legal duty through **Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013 (with Schedule VII listing permitted activities)**. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs' CSR portal calls India **the only country that has regulated and mandated CSR** for select categories of companies. For FY 2024-25 the portal (as read in November 2026) shows **29,546 companies** reporting about **Rs 40,794 crore** of CSR spending.

| **Is CSR efficient and sufficient?**

 | **Arguments**

 |
| Yes, in part

 | Large, steady funding for health, education, sanitation and rural development; a culture of giving back; partnerships with government

 |
| Not efficient

 | Spending clusters in industrial States and easy sectors; some is routed to funds rather than designed projects; outcomes are often measured as money spent, not change achieved

 |
| Not sufficient

 | A share of profit given away cannot offset harm done in the core business: pollution, emissions, displacement, unsafe labour. Responsibility must begin with how profits are made, not how a fraction is spent

 |

**Answer frame:** CSR is a useful floor, not a substitute for responsible business. Add environmental and social accountability in the core: honest climate disclosure, emissions targets, polluter-pays enforcement, fair labour practices, and consultation with communities affected by projects. Gandhi's trusteeship (article 07) gives the moral root: wealth held in trust for society, with production guided by social necessity, not greed.

## Business ethics in case studies

- **Pressure to meet targets** by cutting corners (mis-selling, hiding defects, bribing for contracts): refuse, escalate through internal channels, and use whistleblower protections.

- **Data and technology firms:** privacy, consent, algorithmic bias and safety testing before launch.

- **Hospitals and pharma:** patient welfare over revenue targets; honest trial data; informed consent (article 06).

## Further Reading

- PIB press releases, ministry websites and annual reports, the Gazette of India, MEA and UN documents and the official sources named in each note — the primary sources behind every fact above.

## Test Yourself: Practice Questions & PYQs

12 practice questions, then the GS4 questions on corporate governance.

## Practice Questions

**Q1.** Milton Friedman argued in 1970 that the moral responsibility of business is to

- (a) serve all stakeholders equally

- (b) pay for public services

- (c) avoid all regulation

- (d) increase its profits

**Answer: (d)** — This is the shareholder-primacy view.

**Q2.** Stakeholder theory holds that managers should

- (a) balance the interests of all who have a stake in the firm

- (b) maximise market share

- (c) serve only shareholders

- (d) serve only the government

**Answer: (a)** — Stakeholders include employees, customers, shareholders and communities.

**Q3.** The Firestone/Ford tyre crisis is used to show that

- (a) regulation is never needed

- (b) profit and safety never conflict

- (c) cutting costs on safety can harm the public and the firm

- (d) recalls are always unnecessary

**Answer: (c)** — It involved 271 deaths and recalls costing billions.

**Q4.** According to the 2nd ARC, in Transparency International's Bribe Payers Index 2006, businesses with the greatest propensity to pay bribes were from

- (a) Brazil, Mexico and Argentina

- (b) the USA, UK and Germany

- (c) India, China and Russia

- (d) Japan, Korea and Singapore

**Answer: (c)** — They were at the bottom of the index.

**Q5.** Under the 2018 amendment to the Prevention of Corruption Act, giving an undue advantage to induce a public servant to act improperly is punishable with imprisonment up to

- (a) ten years

- (b) seven years

- (c) three years

- (d) one year

**Answer: (b)** — Or fine, or both.

**Q6.** A commercial organisation charged with bribery under the amended PC Act can defend itself by proving that it had

- (a) no profits that year

- (b) adequate procedures in place to prevent such conduct

- (c) paid the bribe abroad

- (d) a foreign parent company

**Answer: (b)** — This encourages compliance programmes.

**Q7.** Article 12 of the UN Convention against Corruption asks states to prohibit, among other practices,

- (a) CSR spending

- (b) off-the-books accounts

- (c) foreign investment

- (d) public procurement

**Answer: (b)** — It deals with corruption in the private sector.

**Q8.** Why did the 2nd ARC advise against nominating serving officers to PSU boards?

- (a) Political neutrality rules forbid it

- (b) Cost

- (c) Lack of qualifications

- (d) Conflict of interest

**Answer: (d)** — An official may later judge decisions he took as a board member.

**Q9.** India's mandatory CSR provision is in

- (a) the Prevention of Corruption Act

- (b) the RTI Act

- (c) Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013

- (d) Article 51A of the Constitution

**Answer: (c)** — Schedule VII lists the permitted activities.

**Q10.** According to the MCA CSR portal, India is

- (a) the largest CSR spender in the world

- (b) a country with voluntary CSR only

- (c) the only country that has regulated and mandated CSR for select companies

- (d) one of fifty countries with mandatory CSR

**Answer: (c)** — The portal shows about Rs 40,794 crore of CSR for FY 2024-25.

**Q11.** Consider the following statements:
1. CSR spending cannot offset harm done in a company's core business.
2. Outcome measurement of CSR is often weak.
3. CSR makes environmental regulation unnecessary.
Which of the statements given above are correct?

- (a) 1 and 2 only

- (b) 2 and 3 only

- (c) 1 and 3 only

- (d) 1, 2 and 3

**Answer: (a)** — 1 and 2 are correct. Responsibility begins with how profits are made.

**Q12.** Which pair best describes good corporate governance as UPSC framed it in 2023?

- (a) Secrecy and speed

- (b) Moral integrity and professional efficiency

- (c) Loyalty and obedience

- (d) Profit and market share

**Answer: (b)** — Efficiency without integrity breeds fraud; integrity without efficiency breeds failure.

### Mains Practice Questions

Use these to frame full-length answers. You don't have to answer one exactly — they show the angles UPSC tests, so let them guide which points you cover.

- Is CSR efficient and sufficient to meet the social responsibilities of the corporate sector?

- What do moral integrity and professional efficiency mean in corporate governance in India?

- Compare shareholder primacy and stakeholder theory with examples.

### UPSC Mains — Previous Years’ Questions on this topic (last 10 years)

These are the **actual GS Mains questions** UPSC has asked on this theme — real proof of how, and when, it is tested. Try to write a full answer to each.

- 2022 (GS-IV): In contemporary world, corporate sector's contribution in generating wealth and employment is increasing. In doing so, they are bringing in unprecedented onslaught on the climate, environmental sustainability and living conditions of human beings. In this background, do you find that Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is efficient and sufficient enough to fulfill the social roles and responsibilities needed in the corporate world for which the CSR is mandated? Critically examine.

- 2023 (GS-IV): What do you understand by 'moral integrity' and 'professional efficiency' in the context of corporate governance in India? Illustrate with suitable examples.
