Making Himachal Great Again

Main Thread

The Himachal Reality Check: Problems & Solutions

This thread serves as a living archive of the challenges plaguing our society. My goal is not just to complain, but to document the rot I see—unfiltered—and propose actionable, radical solutions.

I will update this thread with detailed analysis and proposed solutions.

Join the debate: If you see a problem that needs attention, or if you have a better solution, drop a comment below. Let’s discuss.

Cheap Tourism

How to Fix the "Cheap Tourist" Problem (A Radical Proposal)

Recently, there has been a massive increase in the number of uneducated, "cheap mentality" tourists in the mountains. Cases of rash driving, drunk driving, and violence against common people or local businesses have spiked.

Who are these people?

These are the modern lowlifes—the stains of India. These types of people contribute nothing to society and are often disliked even by their own communities. They represent the 1% of the most gawaar (uncivilized) people in India. Their contribution to the country is effectively 0%.

They are mostly individuals who survive on rental income and do nothing productive. If their families were to discard them, they wouldn’t even be able to arrange food for themselves.

How to identify them?

I will give you five easy points to differentiate them from decent people. It is usually very obvious:

  1. Modified Vehicles: Look for wide tires and stickers plastered all over the car.

  2. Noise Pollution: Extremely loud music systems with heavy bass.

  3. Public Nuisance: Drinking alcohol openly and throwing empty bottles on the road.

  4. The "Sunroof Langoors": People popping out of sunroofs or hanging out of side windows while the car is moving.

  5. Reckless Driving: Overtaking on single-lane roads and endangering others.

Most of these people will check all the boxes. They are the least civil people around. In fact, most probably, they would be happy reading this description, thinking I am praising them.

What is the current scenario?

Currently, the system is broken. In normal cases, the police seem to only exist to help them get to their hotels and ensure they "sleep well." In rare cases, the police might issue a small fine. The tourists pay it easily and move on. This is not the correct way to deal with the problem.

The Way Forward: A Radical Solution

We need a system that hurts their ego and their wallet. Here is my proposal:

1. The "Bounty" System (Incentivized Reporting) We need heavy fines, but with a twist. The fine amount should be shared 50-50 between the government and the complainant.

  • Minimum Fine: ₹10,000.

  • The Reward: Any local or tourist who complains receives 50% of the fine money (₹5,000).

  • Proof: Video evidence is enough. This makes it easy money for people to report bad behavior, creating a self-policing society.

2. Compulsory "Cooling Off" Zones Fines aren't enough. We need to waste their time. We should create special holding cells or "Restricted Zones" for such tourists where they are kept in custody for at least 48 hours. They cannot leave the premises.

Features of the Restricted Zones:

  • Forced Education: Install LED screens playing tourism videos of important locations so they "don't miss out," but mix it with advertisements teaching basic civic sense.

  • Economic Contribution: Allow Zomato/Swiggy to deliver food to them during custody. This ensures they still contribute to the local economy while locked up.

  • Behavioral Release: Only release people early if they demonstrate improved behavior or attend a civic sense workshop.

3. Anti-Corruption Measures To ensure the police don't just take bribes to let them go, all complaints must be displayed on a dedicated public webpage with the proof video.

  • If someone produces proof that the police did not take action on a valid complaint, the police officer becomes answerable to the judiciary.

  • The penalty? The policeman loses their job, and the complainant receives the full fine money.