# Tribal Communities for UPSC: Who Is a Tribe, the Caste-Tribe Debate, Displacement and Development, and Adivasi Identity

Source: https://tracknation.in/story/tribal-communities-for-upsc-who-is-a-tribe-the-caste-tribe-debate-displacement-and-development-and-adivasi-identity (TrackNation — free UPSC notes with PYQs)

> Tribes for UPSC GS1: permanent and acquired traits, where tribes live, the failed definitions and the caste-tribe continuum, tribes as 'secondary', development and displacement (Narmada, Polavaram), in-migration, adivasi movements and statehood, the tribal middle class, FRA rights and RFCTLARR, with three GS1 PYQs.

## Who Is a Tribe?

🎯 **Exam priority: Important (Mains).** *Tribes were asked in 2021, 2022 and 2025: knowledge systems, whether diverse tribes form one category, and development as displacement and rehabilitation. The welfare schemes (PM-JANMAN, Dharti Aaba, Forest Rights Act) are in the Government Schemes playlist; this article gives the sociology.*

## Who is a tribe?

"Tribe" is a modern term for some of the oldest communities of the subcontinent. They were long defined by what they were *not*: no religion with a written text, no state of the usual kind, no sharp class divisions. Positive classifications use two kinds of trait:

| **Trait**

 | **What the NCERT text records**

 |
| Region (permanent)

 | About 85% live in 'middle India', from Gujarat and Rajasthan to West Bengal and Odisha; over 11% in the North-East, where tribes are over 60% (up to 95%) of the population in Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya, Mizoram and Nagaland

 |
| Language (permanent)

 | Four families: Indo-Aryan and Dravidian (shared with others), Austric and Tibeto-Burman (spoken mainly by tribes)

 |
| Size

 | From the Gonds, Bhils, Santhals, Oraons, Minas, Bodos and Mundas (each over a million) to Andamanese groups of under a hundred

 |
| Livelihood (acquired)

 | Fishers, hunters and gatherers, shifting cultivators, peasants, plantation and industrial workers

 |
| Incorporation (acquired)

 | Degree of assimilation into Hindu society, the classification most used in politics

 |

*Where tribes live and the four language families.*

**Numbers:** Census 2011 counted about 104 million tribal people, **8.6%** of the population; the Government's 2025 count is over **10.45 crore**. There are **75 Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups** in 18 States and 1 Union Territory.

## Tribe: The Career of a Concept

Sociologists have argued for decades about what makes a tribe a tribe.

## Tribe: the career of a concept

- **Continuum or difference?** In the 1960s some saw tribes as one end of a continuum with caste-peasant society, simply less stratified and with community ownership of resources. Others said tribes were wholly different because they had no notion of **purity and pollution**.

- **By the 1970s every major definition was shown to be faulty:** size, isolation, religion and livelihood all failed as tests. Santhals, Gonds and Bhils are huge and spread out; Mundas and Hos took to settled farming long ago; some castes turned to hunting.

- **Absorption:** Indian history is often read as tribes being absorbed into caste society through Sanskritisation, conquest or acculturation. Early anthropologists stressed the cultural side; later writers, the exploitation.

- **Not "pristine":** some scholars see tribes as "secondary" phenomena, formed through contact with states. Adivasis were not always subordinate: there were Gond kingdoms such as Garha Mandla and Chanda, and tribes traded forest produce, salt and elephants.

## When should tribes be one category? (the 2022 question)

Tribes are diverse in language, region, livelihood and degree of integration, and the most vulnerable (the PVTGs) differ sharply from the emerging tribal middle class. They make sense as a single category where they share a **common relationship with the state and the market**: constitutional status and reservations, protection of land and forests, and shared experience of displacement. Elsewhere, policy must be group-specific, which is exactly why PVTGs have their own mission.

## Development, Displacement and Identity

The central question of tribal sociology today is development: whose development, and at whose cost?

## National development versus tribal development

- **A disproportionate price:** dams, factories and mines were built in mineral-rich, forested tribal areas. The Sardar Sarovar dam on the Narmada and the Polavaram dam on the Godavari displaced hundreds of thousands of adivasis; land acquisition became easier after liberalisation in the 1990s.

- **Loss of forests and commons:** forests were exploited from British times on, and private property in land disadvantaged **community ownership**.

- **In-migration:** non-tribal inflows diluted tribal shares in Jharkhand's industrial belt; in Tripura the tribal share was halved within a single decade, turning them into a minority.

- **'Adivasi'**, meaning "original inhabitants", was coined in the 1930s in resistance to colonial intrusion, outside settlers and moneylenders. Like "Dalit", it signals political awareness. Movements won statehood for **Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh**, possible because adivasis, unlike Dalits, live in contiguous areas.

- **Identity today** grows from interaction with the mainstream, not from some primordial essence. An educated **tribal middle class** is emerging, and movements turn on two issues that can diverge: control of land and forests, and ethnic-cultural identity.

## Rights that answer these problems

| **Instrument**

 | **What it gives**

 |
| Forest Rights Act, 2006, Section 3(1)

 | Individual and community rights, including rights to protect and manage community forest resources, habitat rights for PVTGs, and access to biodiversity and the community right to intellectual property and traditional knowledge; 23.88 lakh individual and 1.21 lakh community titles distributed

 |
| RFCTLARR Act, 2013

 | The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act governs compensation and resettlement when land is taken

 |
| Statehood and special laws

 | Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh; Fifth and Sixth Schedule protections (Polity playlist)

 |

## The state's response today

- **Money across ministries:** under the Development Action Plan for Scheduled Tribes, 42 ministries and departments earmark funds, which rose about fivefold from Rs 24,598 crore (2013-14) to Rs 1.23 lakh crore (2024-25).

- **The most vulnerable first:** **PM-JANMAN** (Rs 24,104 crore) aims to saturate PVTG habitations with housing, roads, water, health and education, recognising that the PVTGs need group-specific policy.

- **Villages:** the **Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan**, launched on 2 October 2024 from Hazaribagh, Jharkhand (Rs 79,156 crore), covers about 63,843 tribal-majority villages and aspirational districts.

- **Knowledge and culture:** 29 Tribal Research Institutes document tribal heritage, languages and traditional knowledge.

- **The unresolved part:** the NCERT text notes that several North-Eastern States lived for decades under special laws that limit civil liberties, a reminder that integration has come with security as well as welfare.

## Writing the tribal answers

- **Tribal knowledge systems (2021):** oral, community-owned and tied to ecology (forests, medicinal plants, seeds, water), in contrast to codified, individual, market-oriented knowledge. The FRA's recognition of community intellectual property and traditional knowledge is the legal hook.

- **Displacement and rehabilitation (2025):** agree that development has centred on these two axes, using the Narmada and Polavaram examples and the disproportionate-price argument, then show the alternative: consent, community forest rights, a share in project benefits, and education that builds the tribal middle class without erasing identity.

## Further Reading

- PIB press releases, ministry websites and annual reports, the Gazette of India, MEA and UN documents and the official sources named in each note — the primary sources behind every fact above.

## Test Yourself: Practice Questions & PYQs

12 practice questions, then the three GS Paper 1 questions on tribes.

## Practice Questions

**Q1.** According to the NCERT text, about what share of India's tribal population lives in 'middle India'?

- (a) About 50%

- (b) About 85%

- (c) About 3%

- (d) About 11%

**Answer: (b)** — Over 11% live in the North-East and a little over 3% elsewhere.

**Q2.** Which two language families are spoken primarily by tribal communities?

- (a) Indo-Aryan and Dravidian

- (b) Dravidian and Austric

- (c) Austric and Tibeto-Burman

- (d) Indo-Aryan and Tibeto-Burman

**Answer: (c)** — Tribes are only about 1% of Indo-Aryan and 3% of Dravidian speakers.

**Q3.** Census 2011 put India's tribal population at about

- (a) 8.6% of the population

- (b) 16.6%

- (c) 12.4%

- (d) 5.2%

**Answer: (a)** — About 104 million people.

**Q4.** How many Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) are there?

- (a) 104

- (b) 75

- (c) 62

- (d) 90

**Answer: (b)** — In 18 States and 1 Union Territory.

**Q5.** Scholars who argued that tribes were wholly different from castes stressed that tribes

- (a) were all nomadic

- (b) had no notion of purity and pollution

- (c) were always small

- (d) had no agriculture

**Answer: (b)** — By the 1970s this and other definitions were shown to be faulty.

**Q6.** Which of these was a Gond kingdom in Central India?

- (a) Hoysala

- (b) Kakatiya

- (c) Garha Mandla

- (d) Vijayanagara

**Answer: (c)** — Chanda was another.

**Q7.** The term 'Adivasi', meaning 'original inhabitants', was coined in the

- (a) 1880s

- (b) 1970s

- (c) 1930s

- (d) 1950s

**Answer: (c)** — In the struggle against colonial intrusion, outside settlers and moneylenders.

**Q8.** Which two States were created after long adivasi movements?

- (a) Goa and Sikkim

- (b) Telangana and Uttarakhand

- (c) Mizoram and Nagaland

- (d) Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh

**Answer: (d)** — Adivasis live in contiguous areas and could demand States of their own.

**Q9.** In which State, according to the NCERT text, did the tribal share of the population halve within a single decade?

- (a) Tripura

- (b) Mizoram

- (c) Odisha

- (d) Jharkhand

**Answer: (a)** — In-migration of non-tribals turned them into a minority.

**Q10.** Consider the following statements:
1. Section 3(1) of the Forest Rights Act recognises the community right to intellectual property and traditional knowledge.
2. It recognises habitat rights for primitive tribal groups.
3. It allows the sale of tribal forest land to private buyers.
Which of the statements given above are correct?

- (a) 1 and 2 only

- (b) 2 and 3 only

- (c) 1 and 3 only

- (d) 1, 2 and 3

**Answer: (a)** — 1 and 2 are correct. Forest rights are heritable but not alienable or transferable.

**Q11.** The Sardar Sarovar and Polavaram dams are cited in the NCERT text as examples of

- (a) tribal self-governance

- (b) community forest management

- (c) displacement of adivasis by development projects

- (d) Sanskritisation

**Answer: (c)** — They displaced hundreds of thousands of adivasis.

**Q12.** Which Act governs compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement when land is acquired?

- (a) Forest Conservation Act, 1980

- (b) PESA Act, 1996

- (c) RFCTLARR Act, 2013

- (d) Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (still in force)

**Answer: (c)** — The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.

### Mains Practice Questions

Use these to frame full-length answers. You don't have to answer one exactly — they show the angles UPSC tests, so let them guide which points you cover.

- Does tribal development in India centre around displacement and rehabilitation? Give your opinion.

- Given their diversity, when should tribal communities be considered a single category?

- What makes tribal knowledge systems distinct, and how can the law protect them?

### UPSC Mains — Previous Years’ Questions on this topic (last 10 years)

These are the **actual GS Mains questions** UPSC has asked on this theme — real proof of how, and when, it is tested. Try to write a full answer to each.

- 2021 (GS-I): Examine the uniqueness of tribal knowledge system when compared with mainstream knowledge and cultural systems.

- 2022 (GS-I): Given the diversities among tribal communities in India, in which specific contexts should they be considered as a single category?

- 2025 (GS-I): Does tribal development in India centre around two axes, those of displacement and of rehabilitation? Give your opinion.
